A link in the menu appears on every page, so the menu is the site's loudest claim about what it is. Presteigne Wines in Powys had a mega menu carrying every region, every grape and every price band. 40 items in a menu is 40 claims of equal importance, which is none.
In February 2026 the menu went from 40 items to 14 and six pages moved up, the largest of them from position 12 to 5. Nothing that was removed from the menu fell, because the pages removed were reachable from their category pages and were never getting anything from being in a list of forty.
Why the arithmetic works that way
Every page on the site links to every menu item. That is not forty endorsements, it is one arrangement repeated, and dividing the site's own attention forty ways leaves each item with a fortieth of a claim. Fourteen ways leaves each with more, which is the whole mechanism and it is nearly arithmetic.
Link arithmetic
Forty equal claims in a mega menu against fourteen category links
Because the menu repeats on every page, trimming unused links concentrates attention on the hubs that matter.
- 40-item mega menuSite-wide dilution
- Every item gets a fortieth of a claim
- 26 items saw under five clicks a month
- Products compete directly with categories
- 14-item category menuCategories first, products below
- Six regions, three styles, five utility links
- 26 removed links sit on region pages
- Browsers still find every wine one click down
Menu attention split
Removing a low-click link from the top menu stops spending site-wide attention without hiding the page.
Put the categories in the menu and the products one click below. Presteigne's menu now carries six regions, three styles and five utility links, and the 26 that came off sit on region pages where a person looking for Loire whites would actually be. Nobody browsing lost anything: a menu item nobody clicks is still spending the site's attention, and 26 of the 40 had fewer than five clicks a month between them.
Naming, and the trade word problem
Name a menu item what a customer would call it, not what the trade calls it. The old menu had an item called Biodynamic, which is precise and is a word most of the shop's customers have never used. It is now under a heading called How it was grown, and the biodynamic page sits inside it with its own name intact.
Naming
Bridging trade terms to the words customers search
Top-level menu items follow customer language while specialized pages keep their exact names one click deeper.
- 01Top label: How it was grownReplaces Biodynamic at the top bar where most shoppers never use the word.
- 02Child page: BiodynamicKeeps its accurate title inside the plain parent category.
- 03Settled by search queriesGuided by what buyers type rather than internal team opinion.
Menu wording is a marketing choice before it is a structural one.
This is the one navigation decision that is a marketing decision rather than a structural one, and it is settled by looking at what people type rather than by arguing, which is reading demand instead of guessing it.
The two menus nobody edits
The footer is a menu too, and it is usually nobody's decision. Presteigne's footer carried 22 links including three that pointed at pages deleted in 2024, and it appears on every page exactly like the main menu does. It is now nine links, and the three broken ones are gone.
Navigation
The four navigational surfaces on one page, and who edits each
Three of the four appear on every page of the site, while breadcrumbs explain where a search visitor landed.
- 01Regions Styles Growers Offers About Trade
- 02Home > Regions > Loire
- 03Muscadet is the one to start with, and Sancerre is the one people mean
- 01The main menu14 items now, 40 before. The only surface anybody argues about.
- 02The breadcrumbSays where the page sits to a person who arrived from a search.
- 03The links inside the textWritten by whoever wrote the paragraph, and never discussed.
- 04The footerNine links now. Three of the old 22 pointed at pages deleted in 2024.
Drawn from the spec rather than from a screenshot. The frame shows what is on every page and not the products, which are one click below the menu on purpose.
Breadcrumbs say where a page sits, and they are read by both audiences. A person landing on a wine page from a search has no idea what site they are on or what else is there, and a breadcrumb answers both in one line. Presteigne added them in the same fortnight and the effect on search is not separable from everything else, which is worth admitting rather than claiming.
Where this stalls: the menu as a meeting
The menu is the one piece of structure that gets argued over in a room, because everybody can see it, and the argument is always about what to add. Nobody has ever proposed removing a menu item on the grounds that it dilutes the others, and that is the sentence this page exists to supply.
Blind spot
What teams argue over in meetings against what steers authority
Every debate adds items to the visible menu while far more internal links sit unexamined inside body copy.
- Top navigation barEveryone sees it, so meetings almost always push to add one more link.
- Declared site menuWhat teams believe they are telling crawlers about site priorities.
- Dilution cost of additionsNobody volunteers to remove an item so the remaining ones gain weight.
- Links inside paragraphsFar more numerous, rarely audited, and actively routing authority.
Declared structure and actual structure drift apart whenever body links go unreviewed.
The corresponding blindness is that the links inside paragraphs are never discussed at all, and there are far more of them. The declared structure and the actual structure drift apart in exactly that gap, and the actual one is sending authority where you want it.
What to check, including on a phone
A dropdown that needs a hover is unreachable on a phone. Presteigne's old menu opened on hover and its sub items could not be reached on a touch screen at all, which meant two thirds of the shop's visitors saw a menu with six items in it and never knew about the other 34.
Verification
Three checks that confirm a menu change worked on phone and desktop
Mobile usability, crawl depth, and Search Console positions together prove the restructure helped without dropping pages.
- Exposes hidden sub-items
- Pairs depth shift with rank
- Confirms phone visitors reach links
- Touch-screen menu check
- Screaming Frog crawl depth
- Search Console positions
- Touch-screen menu checkHover-only dropdowns hid 34 sub-items from two thirds of visitors on phones.
- Screaming Frog crawl depthConfirmed 26 moved pages shifted from depth one to depth two cleanly.
- Search Console positionsShowed six pages climbing and zero falling after the fortnight change.
- Touch-screen menu check — Screaming Frog crawl depthExposes hidden sub-items
- Screaming Frog crawl depth — Search Console positionsPairs depth shift with rank
- Search Console positions — Touch-screen menu checkConfirms phone visitors reach links
Search Console replaced analytics keyword data removed in 2011 and verified nothing lost rank.
Screaming Frog SEO Spider reports how many internal links point at each address and at what crawl depth, free up to a few hundred addresses, which is how a menu change is measured. It replaced trying to remember which pages link where, and the number that moved at Presteigne is depth: 26 pages went from depth one to depth two and none of them fell.
Search Console shows the positions either side of the change, free, and it replaced the keyword data Google removed from analytics in 2011. Six pages up and none down is the whole result, and it is a small enough site that nothing else changed in that fortnight except the breadcrumbs.
Which pages deserve to be in the fourteen is a hub, its supporting pages, and the links between, and the addresses those menu items point at are readable, stable and shallow. Both are inside how pages relate, which decides what a site is about.