Faragiri

Learn Photoshop Tools · The basics, Selections and masking, Layers and adjustments and 3 more

A bakery interior retouched: the four non destructive moves, the order that removes an object, and why the working file is 412 MB when the photograph is 38.

6Branches
6Nodes below
3Depth

Photoshop edits pixels, and a pixel that has been changed is gone. Everything that separates a working file from a ruined one is a set of habits for changing pixels without changing them, and there are four.

Ines is retouching a photograph of a bakery interior for a magazine: a fire extinguisher to remove from the middle of the frame, a window blown out to bring back, and a colour cast from the tungsten lights. Three edits, and none of them touches the original layer.

The four non destructive moves

Adjustment layers for anything about tone or colour. A curves adjustment sits above the photograph and changes nothing in it, so the tungsten cast is corrected by a layer that can be turned off in a year by somebody who does not know why it is there.

The same three edits, twice

What each way of working can still be undone in a year

Both files look identical on screen and only one of them can be changed by somebody who was not there.

Edited directlyFast, small file, and every decision is baked in
Adjustments, smart objects and masks412 MB, and every decision still has a switch
The tungsten castPixels changedA curves layer, turn it off
The extinguisherDeleted, then filledFilled on a layer above, masked
Scaled to 40 per cent and backSoft forever, immediatelySharp, from the original pixels
Changing the crop next yearRedo everythingMove a mask
File size38 MB412 MB

The left column is the right answer for a one off web graphic nobody will reopen. It becomes the wrong answer the moment a second person or a second version exists.

Smart objects for anything that gets scaled or filtered. Convert the layer first, and a smart object remembers its original pixels, so scaling to 40 per cent and back leaves it sharp. A normal layer scaled down and up again is soft forever, and it is soft immediately, silently, at the moment somebody was fixing something else.

Masks for anything about where. Black hides and white shows on a mask, which is one sentence and the whole of masking: paint black to hide part of a layer, paint white to bring it back, and nothing is deleted at any point. A selection that gets deleted is a decision; the same selection as a mask is an opinion.

And layer groups with their own masks, for edits that belong together. The window recovery is three layers in one group with one mask over all of them, so the edge of the recovery is adjusted in one place rather than three. The full argument for the habit is non destructive editing, and why it matters.

Selections, and the two that matter

Most cutting out is done by two tools and the rest are situational. Select Subject and the object selection tool get within a few pixels of anything with a defined edge, which is the fire extinguisher, and the remaining work is a mask refinement rather than a selection.

Two selection paths

Match the selection tool to the edge you are cutting

Automated object selection handles hard edges cleanly, while hair and soft edges need Select and Mask with colour decontamination.

What kind of boundary surrounds the subject?
  • Defined solid edge
    Select Subject and object selectionLands within a few pixels on objects like the fire extinguisher
    • Grab the initial shape quickly
    • Clean up the remainder on a layer mask
  • Hair or soft fringe
    Select and Mask workspaceSeparates fine strands without leaving a pasted halo
    • Paint edges with the refine edge brush
    • Enable decontaminate colours to clear old background spill

Treat every selection as the start of a mask rather than a final deletion.

Hair is the exception and it has its own panel. Select and Mask with the refine edge brush is the thing that works, and the setting that matters is decontaminate colours, which removes the fringe of the old background that otherwise makes a cut out look pasted. Cutting cleanly, including the hard cases, is cutting things out cleanly, including hair.

Removing an object is three tools, in order

Generative fill for the bulk, the clone stamp for the parts it invents badly, and the healing brush for the seams. That order matters: the generative pass fills the extinguisher's space with plausible tiled wall in one operation, then it invents a light switch that was never there, then the clone stamp removes the light switch by copying from a real part of the same wall.

Three tools, in order

How to remove an unwanted object without leaving synthetic seams

Let generative fill clear the bulk first, then replace invented details with real texture and blend the edges last.

  1. 01Generative fillReplaces the extinguisher's footprint with plausible tiled wall in one pass
  2. 02Clone stampRemoves invented artefacts like a stray light switch using real wall pixels
  3. 03Healing brushSmooths the boundary seams where cloned patches meet the original lighting

Tool sequence is mechanical; deciding what may ethically be removed depends on whether the image is editorial or news.

The judgement about how far to take it belongs to the job rather than the tool. A magazine interior can lose a fire extinguisher; a news photograph cannot lose anything at all, and the same three tools are involved in both. Where that line sits is skin, objects and restraint, and putting several photographs together so they pass as one is several images passing as one photograph.

The file gets heavy, and it is not the photograph

The bakery file is 412 MB and the photograph in it is 38 MB. The rest is the working method: 210 MB of smart objects holding their original pixels, 96 MB of layer masks, 44 MB of history and cached previews, and 24 MB of embedded profiles and metadata. That is the price of everything above, it is worth paying, and it is worth knowing so that nobody flattens the file to make it open faster.

One working file

Where 412 MB goes, and how little of it is the photograph

Nine parts in ten of this file is the method rather than the picture, which is the reason not to flatten it.

Megabytes in the layered bakery file, read from the file info panel. The magazine is invented; the proportions are ordinary.

412 MBThe layered original, kept
  1. Smart objectsOriginal pixels held so a scale can be undone210 MB
  2. Layer masksWhere each edit applies, kept as greyscale rather than as a deletion96 MB
  3. History and previewsDiscarded on close, and the only part that is genuinely waste44 MB
  4. The photographThe thing the file is of38 MB
  5. Profiles and metadataIncluding the colour profile that decides how it prints24 MB

Flattening returns almost all of this and costs every future edit. The only slice worth reclaiming is the history, which goes on its own when the file is closed.

Never flatten the file you keep. Export a flat copy for whoever needs one, and keep the layered original, because the layered original is the only version any future change can be made in.

The stall is learning effects before the export dialog

Blend modes, filters, layer styles: they are the fun part, they are what tutorials are made of, and they produce a visible result in one click. Meanwhile the file goes to a printer in the wrong colour space, or to a developer at the wrong size, or as a JPEG at quality 12 that is four megabytes on a phone.

After the retouch leaves

Why clean edits still fail when export settings go unchecked

Tutorials focus on blend modes and filters, while wrong colour profiles and quality-12 JPEGs break the file after handoff.

Export hygiene before delivery

  1. YesIntentional colour profile chosenStops the bakery image from turning muddy on pressYes
  2. YesPixel dimensions matched to targetPrevents handing full-scale print buffers to web developersYes
  3. NoLast user's export default acceptedShips whatever stale colour space the dialog rememberedNo
  4. NoJPEG saved at quality 12 for phonesTurns a screen asset into four megabytes with no visible gainNo

If you cannot name the colour profile on your last export and explain why you picked it, the export dialog is driving the job.

That is where Photoshop work stalls, and it is invisible because the picture is fine and the failure happens after it leaves. The tell is one question. Name the colour profile your last export carried and the reason for it. If the answer is that the default was accepted, the file has been leaving in whatever state the dialog remembered from the last person, and that is where the bakery photograph turned muddy on press. The export half, and artboards for screen work, is artboards, exports and handoff.

What to open

Photoshop itself is the standard and there is no free path, only a trial. What is worth setting on day one is the colour setting rather than any tool: working in sRGB for anything going to a screen and in a CMYK profile the printer names for anything going to press, decided once, in the colour settings dialog, and never per file.

Raster editing options

Adobe Photoshop compared with Affinity Photo for layered retouching

Set sRGB for screen or the printer's CMYK profile on day one; both tools handle layered PSD files while differing on pricing and generative fill.

  • Adobe PhotoshopSubscription standard
    • Stronger generative fill tools
    • Central colour settings dialog
    • Ongoing subscription after trial
  • Affinity PhotoOne-time purchase alternative
    • Opens layered Photoshop files
    • Competitive core retouching tools
    • Lighter generative fill capability

Layered raster retouching

Neither tool replaces Illustrator or InDesign when a job is mostly three lines of vector type.

Affinity Photo is the one time purchase alternative and it opens layered Photoshop files, which is the only test that matters for anybody joining a job halfway through. It replaced the subscription as the price of doing this work, and it is genuinely competitive for retouching, if less so for the generative tools.

What none of this covers is which program the job wanted in the first place, because a poster with three lines of type on it is not a Photoshop job however comfortable the program is: vectors: logos, icons and illustration. The retouching judgement above rests on seeing what is actually in the frame, which is the skill under all the others, and how it is trained, and the press behaviour that ruins a file after export is what changes when it leaves the screen.

Inside this, 6

Above this