Faragiri

Learn Layers and adjustments Photoshop

A Porto Alegre cover at 2.4 GB flattened to make it usable, and a sky rebuilt over a day and a half that is very slightly different.

7Sections
4Min read
4Depth

A pixel that has been changed is gone. Every habit on this page exists to change what an image looks like without changing what it is, and the test of a file is whether the edit made on Monday can be undone on Friday.

Bruno prepares images for a magazine in Porto Alegre: a cover shot that goes through four rounds with an editor, each round asking for something the last round asked to be removed.

Five layers, in an order

Bottom to top: the original untouched, the retouching, the local adjustments, the global adjustments, and the output. Every file has those five and nothing else, and the order is what makes each one revisable.

One cover, four rounds

Five slabs, and each one rests on the one below

Nothing here is a step in a process. It is a dependency order, and the only layer that is safe to delete is the one on top.

  1. Outputa stamped copy carrying sharpening and grain, remade rather than adjusted, deleted first
  2. Global adjustmentscurves and colour with no mask, affecting everything, and the layer an editor asks about
  3. Local adjustmentsthe same kinds of layer with masks, so a request about the sky cannot touch a face
  4. Retouchingan empty layer sampling all layers, so the removed lamp post can be switched off
  5. The originaluntouched, and the reason the worst afternoon costs four layers rather than the image

Groups cut across this stack rather than sitting in it: one group per round of comments, each with its own mask, which is how round four gets shown what round two did.

The original is never touched, which is the whole foundation. Duplicate it, work above it, and the worst outcome of any afternoon is that the top four layers get deleted.

Retouching goes on an empty layer set to sample all layers. The healing brush and the clone stamp both do this, and it means the removed lamp post lives on its own layer and can be turned off, which the editor will ask for.

Adjustments come in two kinds

Local adjustments carry a mask and global ones do not. Brightening a face is local: a curves layer with a mask that is black everywhere except the face. Warming the whole image is global: the same curves layer with no mask at all.

Two kinds of adjustment

Separate masked local fixes from whole-frame colour moves

Combining a face fix and a global colour grade on one layer means revising warmth later forces you to re-edit the face.

What should this edit or transform affect?
  • Only one subject or region
    Masked local adjustmentKeeps face brightening isolated from overall warmth
    • Add a curves layer with a black mask
    • Paint white only over the face
    • Adjust global tone later without touching the subject
  • Whole image, scaling, or filters
    Unmasked global layer or smart objectApplies cleanly across the frame while keeping pixels intact
    • Leave global colour layers unmasked for quick toggling
    • Convert to a smart object before scaling or filtering
    • Reopen filters or resize back up without pixel mush

Converting a layer to a smart object before any scale or filter keeps the original pixels safe underneath.

Keeping them on separate layers means the editor's request to warm it slightly less does not touch the face, which is what happens when the two are combined into one adjustment because it looked simpler at the time.

Anything scaled or filtered becomes a smart object first. A smart object keeps the original pixels and applies the transform on the way out, so an image scaled down and then back up is not the mush it would otherwise be, and a filter applied to one can be reopened and changed.

Groups are for edits that belong together

Group the layers that answer one request, and mask the group. Round two's changes go in a group called round-2, with its own mask, and turning that group off shows the editor exactly what round two did.

Four rounds with an editor

Masked round groups let Friday undo Wednesday in one click

Putting every comment batch inside its own named, masked folder makes returning to an earlier version effortless.

  1. Round 1Base layers establishedInitial retouching and tone adjustments sit clean at the bottom
  2. Round 2Isolated in group round-2All edits requested in the second review stay inside one masked folder
  3. Round 3Layered in its own folderNew sky and colour changes sit above round-2 without erasing it
  4. Round 4Toggle round-2 visibilitySwitching one group off and on shows the editor exactly what changed

Round four almost always asks for something from round two, so keeping round-2 intact saves rebuilding from scratch.

That is worth more than it sounds on a file with four rounds in it, because the fourth round is usually a request to go back to something from the second.

What the top layer is

The output layer is a stamped copy, made last and deleted first. Sharpening, grain and any final compression artefact live there, on a merged copy at the top of the stack, and it is remade rather than adjusted whenever anything below it changes.

The top output layer

Stamped last, deleted first whenever anything below changes

Sharpening and grain live on a single merged copy at the top of the stack rather than baked into the master layers.

Output stamp rule

  • 01Adjust layers underneath
  • 02Stamp a merged top copy
  • 03Apply sharpening and grain
  • 04Delete stamp on next edit
  1. 01Adjust layers underneathMake every tone, mask, or retouch revision below the top slab
  2. 02Stamp a merged top copyBuild one combined layer at the top only when edits are ready
  3. 03Apply sharpening and grainKeep final print or export artefacts strictly on that top stamp
  4. 04Delete stamp on next editThrow away the old stamp and re-stamp instead of patching it

Export a flattened deliverable copy for print, while always keeping the layered master file under a clear separate name.

Never flatten the file you keep. Export a flattened copy, keep the layered one, and name them so nobody has to guess which is which. A flattened master is a file that has been finished on purpose.

What to open

Adjustment layers and smart objects are both built into Photoshop, and there is no free tier. Between them they cover everything on this page, and the only discipline required is using them from the first edit rather than converting later, because a filter already applied cannot be un-applied by making the layer smart afterwards.

What to open

Session undo disappears; smart layers survive across weeks

Photoshop includes both built-in protections with no free tier, but only one of them persists after you close the document.

  • History panelAlready open as a within-session safety net, but vanishes once the file closes
Closing the document
  • Adjustment layersNon-destructive tone and colour controls editable across every future round
  • Smart objects applied upfrontProtects pixel integrity permanently, provided you convert before filtering

A filter applied directly to pixels cannot be reversed by turning the layer into a smart object afterwards.

The history panel is the free part of the same idea, already open, and it replaces undoing repeatedly and losing everything after the mistake. It is a within-session safety net rather than a structure, which is why it is not a substitute for the five layers.

Where it stalls: flattening because the file is slow

A layered file on a large image is heavy, and a heavy file is slow, and flattening makes it fast. The moment always arrives and it always arrives at the end of a long day.

Where it stalls

Temporary file slowness beats permanent flattened regret

Flattening speeds up a sluggish file at the end of a long day, but trades one person's brief relief for permanent loss.

  • Keep layers, reduce loadCost paid by one editor for an afternoon
    • Turn off the top stamped output layer while working
    • Close other open documents to free memory
    • Preserve every mask and round folder for next week
  • Flatten to speed upCost paid by everyone for the life of the file
    • Brushes respond faster tonight
    • Masks, adjustment curves, and round groups vanish
    • Future revisions require rebuilding from raw

Who pays the price

Speed up the session by hiding heavy top stamps rather than destroying the structure below.

What follows is a file that works beautifully and cannot be revised, which is discovered a week later by somebody who was not there. The layers were not deleted carelessly; they were deleted for a real reason at a real moment.

The answer is to make the slowness go away instead: turn off the top output layer while working, close the other documents, and let the file be heavy. A slow file is a cost paid by one person for an afternoon, and a flattened one is a cost paid by everybody for the life of the image.

What it looks like when it goes wrong

The cover was flattened at the end of round three, at eleven at night, because it had reached 2.4 GB and had begun to stall on every brush stroke. Round four asked for the sky from round two, which had been replaced in round three. There was no round two, no sky layer and no mask, so the sky was rebuilt from the original raw file over a day and a half and it is very slightly different, which the art director noticed and could not name.

Porto Alegre cover incident

How flattening at 2.4 GB cost a day and a half of raw rebuilding

Merging layers at eleven at night solved brush lag in round three and broke round four the next morning.

What felt like a clean finish at eleven at night left no trace of round two when morning arrived.

The masks that every local adjustment depends on start as selections, which is cutting things out cleanly, including hair. Several images stacked and made to agree in one frame is several images passing as one photograph. And the retouching layer's real subject, and where it should stop, is skin, objects and restraint. What the program is for here is one level up, in pixels: retouching, compositing and screen design.

Alongside this

Above this