Faragiri

Learn CollocationsVocabulary

Make a photo breaks no rule and is said by nobody. This is the layer where correct English still sounds wrong, and it cannot be reasoned out from meanings.

6Sections
4Min read
4Depth

Counted, not reasoned

Both columns are grammatical and only one of them is said

Nothing in the meanings predicts a single row here, which is why this cannot be worked out and has to be met.

English saysCounted in real text, not derived from anything
English does not sayGrammatical, clear, and never produced
a photographtake a photomake a photo
an errormake a mistakedo a mistake
the dishesdo the washing upmake the washing up
rainheavy rainstrong rain
teastrong teapowerful tea

Tea and an engine are both things that can be intense, and English hands one of them strong and the other powerful. No row here is an exception to a rule, because there was never a rule.

Make a photo breaks no rule. Every word is right, the grammar is right, the meaning arrives intact, and no English speaker says it. This is the layer where a sentence can be entirely correct and still be wrong, and the only route to being right is to have counted rather than to have thought.

That is worth accepting early, because the reflex is to look for the logic. There is none to find. A photograph is taken and a decision is made, and if the two had swapped in the seventeenth century nobody would find it odd today.

Eight partnerships worth having exactly right

Each of these is a fixed pairing. The logical alternative is grammatical and wrong, which is what makes them worth learning as single items.

  • make a decision, never do one. Make is for creating; do is for performing.
  • do the washing up, and do the shopping, the housework and your homework. Tasks take do.
  • heavy rain, not strong rain, and also heavy traffic and a heavy smoker.
  • strong coffee, not heavy coffee, and also a strong accent and a strong opinion.
  • take a photograph, and take a break, a seat, a shower and a taxi.
  • pay attention, and pay a visit or a compliment, none of which involve money.
  • catch a cold, and catch a bus or a glimpse.
  • keep a promise, and keep a secret, a diary, in touch and calm.

Four verbs that mean nothing and decide everything

Make, do, take and have carry almost no meaning of their own in these pairings. The noun carries it, and the verb is there because English requires a verb: you make a decision, take a photo, do the washing up and have a look, and each choice is convention rather than sense.

Because the verb is empty, nothing about the situation tells you which one to reach for, and a learner has to store the pairing rather than derive it. Four verbs and a few hundred nouns is a real amount of storage, and it is the single largest block of pure convention anywhere in English vocabulary.

Where it stops: make against do

These two never separate for a very large share of learners, and it is the longest-surviving vocabulary error in the language. If your first language uses one verb where English uses two, which is true of Persian, Turkish and a long list of others, there is nothing in your intuition to split them, and the split is not describable as a rule that would help.

Do a mistake is understood by everybody who hears it, and that is exactly the problem. It never costs a sentence, so no listener repairs it, and a speaker can arrive at a high level having said it several thousand times. When it is finally pointed at, the usual reaction is that nobody had ever mentioned it before, which is almost always true.

Partners are specific, even among words that mean the same

Two words with nearly identical meanings often take completely different partners. Tea is strong and never powerful; an engine is powerful and not usually strong. Rain is heavy, and so is traffic, and so is a smoker, and none of that follows from weight.

This is why a thesaurus is a dangerous instrument for a learner. It hands you five words with the same meaning and no information at all about which nouns each of them is allowed to stand beside, and swapping one for another is the most reliable way to produce a sentence that is correct and audibly foreign.

Reading the partners off a corpus

SkELL is the practical tool: free to use in a browser and built for exactly this. Type a word and it returns the words that genuinely appear beside it, sorted by how strongly they attract each other, so rain comes back with heavy at the top and strong nowhere. It replaced asking a native speaker, who will give you a confident opinion about a pairing they have never consciously noticed.

Use it in the direction that pays. Look up the noun and read the verbs and adjectives that arrive with it, rather than looking up the verb you had already chosen and hoping to see it confirmed. The second approach finds something every time and teaches nothing, because almost any two English words appear together somewhere.

What it looks like when it goes wrong

Do a mistake, make a photo, say a lie, strong rain. Four sentences that no reader will stumble over and that a native speaker will notice inside a second, without being able to explain what happened. That combination, invisible cost and instant recognition, is what makes this layer the last one to be repaired in almost every learner.

The unit you have to store here is a pair rather than a word, which is the same lesson arriving from a different direction in in, on, at, and the ones no rule explains. Pairings whose meaning cannot be recovered from either half are phrases that do not mean what their words say, and all of this sits under building the word count you need to say what you mean.

Where this costs the most is the band where the words are near-synonyms to begin with and the partners are the only thing separating them, which is the vocabulary of argument rather than of everyday life: the vocabulary that carries essays, papers and lectures.

Alongside this

Above this